What a trade really costs you: the math almost nobody does

Hi trader,
on Friday we talked about backtests that are too good, and one of the five traps was costs left out “to keep it simple”.
Today I’m answering the question that comes right after: ok, but how much do they really weigh?
Because almost everyone knows what a commission costs.
Almost nobody knows what a trade costs.
Which isn’t the same thing.
The partner you didn’t choose
Every time you open and close a position, someone gets paid, whether you win or lose.
The broker, the exchange, sometimes the platform provider.
It’s a silent partner. It never says a word, never complains, and takes its cut on every trade, even the ones you close at a loss.
And this is exactly the point: what matters isn’t how much it takes in euros. What matters is how much it takes compared to what you make on an average trade.
Let’s go through the items, one by one.
The items on the bill
Commissions and exchange fees. You always pay them, on the way in and on the way out. On a future like the ES, with a cheap broker, we’re talking about 4-5 dollars round turn per contract, exchange fees included. On Eurex’s DAX it’s more or less the same, in euros.
Slippage on stops. A stop market order, when it triggers, becomes a market order.
In quiet moments it fills you at your price. In fast moments, which are exactly when stops get hit in clusters, it fills you a tick or two worse, and on news even more.
A limit that’s sitting in the book, on the other hand, won’t fill you worse than your price, at most it won’t fill you. That’s why in the example that follows I only put slippage on the stops.
The spread, if you trade CFDs. On a CFD you almost never pay a separate commission. You pay it inside the spread, the difference between the price you buy at and the price you sell at. On the DAX, during liquid hours, many brokers sit around one point. At night and on news it widens.
Financing, if you hold a CFD overnight. This is where a lot of people get a surprise. The overnight cost of a CFD is calculated on the full value of the position, not on the margin you put up. For intraday traders who close before the broker’s evening rollover, it’s zero. Watch out for Fridays: many brokers charge three days in one go. For anyone holding positions for days or weeks, it becomes a real item.
Fixed costs. Platform, real-time data, subscriptions. You don’t pay them per trade, but they have to be divided by the trades you make. A hundred dollars a month over forty trades is two and a half dollars per trade. Have you ever put them on the bill?
Same cost, two different traders
Now let’s do the math, with round numbers and an example made up on purpose.
Two traders on the ES. Same platform, same broker, same costs.
One ES tick is worth 12.50 dollars, one point is worth 50.
Both win 55% of the time, with stop and target at the same distance.
The first one scalps: 2-point target, 2-point stop.
Every winning trade is worth 100 dollars, every losing trade 100. Over a hundred trades the average gross profit is 10 dollars per trade.
Now the costs: 4.50 in commissions on every trade, and let’s say half the stops slip by one tick.
Over a hundred trades there are 45 stops, 22 and a half of them slip, at 12.50 dollars each: on average another 2.80 dollars per trade.
Total costs: about 7.30 dollars per trade.
Out of the 10 gross dollars, he’s left with less than 3.
The silent partner took almost three quarters of his edge.
The second one trades wider: 10-point target, 10-point stop.
Same 55%. The average gross profit becomes 50 dollars per trade.
The costs are exactly the same, 7.30 dollars.
He’s left with more than 42. The partner took 15%.
Same market, same broker, same win rate. The first one works mostly for the broker, the second one mostly for himself.
I’m not saying scalping can’t be done. I’m saying that the smaller your target, the more costs become the main character, and your margin for error gets eaten up fast.
The math in ticks
The simplest way to understand how much the partner weighs is to stop thinking in euros and start thinking in ticks.
Take the total cost of a trade, round turn, and divide it by the value of one tick on your instrument.
On the ES, 4.50 dollars divided by 12.50 is about a third of a tick. Not much.
On Eurex’s DAX the tick is a full point and it’s worth 25 euros: a little over four euros in commissions is about a sixth of a tick.
Now do the same math on the small contracts, the ones people use when they start with a small account. The commission goes down, but the tick value goes down a lot more. On some micros the commission is worth a full tick, and sometimes even more.
We’ll talk about it on Wednesday, because micros deserve a piece of their own.
For today this is enough: the same trade, on the same market, can cost three times as much in ticks, and even more, depending on the contract you choose.
What about CFDs?
On a CFD you do the same math with the spread.
If the spread on the DAX is one point and your target is ten points, you’ve already paid 10% of the target before you even start.
If the target is five points, you’ve paid 20%.
And since you pay the spread on every trade, winners and losers, the real weight on your edge is even higher than that, for the same reason you saw with the scalper.
Then there’s financing. Let’s take a round example: a DAX CFD with a value of 20,000 euros, held open for a month, with an annual cost around 5%. That’s roughly 80 euros in interest, whether you put up 1,000 euros of margin or 20,000.
For intraday traders who close in the evening, it doesn’t exist.
For anyone who holds, it has to go on the bill before opening, not be discovered afterwards on the statement.
The test: how much does your partner take?
Ok, vamos. Practical homework, it’ll take you ten minutes.
- Take your last fifty trades.
- Add up everything you paid: commissions, fees, financing. If you trade CFDs, add the spread: number of trades times average spread times point value. If your broker gives it to you in a report, even better.
- Take the net result of the trades and add the sum from step 2: that’s your gross.
- Divide the first sum by the second.
That number is its share.
If it’s under 20%, the partner weighs little.
If it’s over 50%, you’re working more for the broker than for yourself. And before looking for a better setup, it might be worth looking at your target, your frequency or your instrument.
If your gross result is negative, costs aren’t your main problem. But they’re digging the hole faster.
To do this math you need to know how much you paid trade by trade. If you don’t have a place to log it, the TradingBlog Diary is free and shows you the net result of every trade instead of the one you remember.
And if you trade Forex or CFDs and want to know what a pip or a point is worth before you get in, the Lot Size Calculator does the math for you.
One note before I wrap up
I’m not saying just pick the cheapest broker and be done with it.
A broker that costs a dollar less per trade but fills you badly, or leaves you without a platform at the wrong moment, costs you more.
I’m saying something else: you need to know the cost of a trade before you open it, in ticks or in points, and put it next to your target.
Because the silent partner never quits.
But at least you can decide how much to pay it.
Your broker is a partner who takes a cut of every trade, even the ones you lose. At least know how much you are paying.
Suerte Amigo!
Tiziano Brunno
Tradingblog
Want to put your market reading to the test?
Compete and challenge other traders inside an Arena in a demo environment, with no real capital at risk. Discover the Performance Arena Events by The Thunder Trader.
Disclaimer: purely informational and educational content. It does not constitute financial advice or an invitation to trade. Trading involves the risk of capital loss.



