Posts

The entrance turnstiles of a large industrial plant at dawn, with the factory hall windows glowing amber and mist drifting across the yard.

October NFP: the jobs data lands the day after the Nasdaq crash

Hi trader,

yesterday the Nasdaq lost 5.5%.

It’s the worst day since April 2025, according to CNBC.

And today, at 8:30 New York time (13:30 GMT), the macro data that moves US markets more than any other comes out: the October employment report, the one everyone calls the NFP.

It doesn’t happen often that the most awaited data of the month lands on a market that has just stepped out of the ring with a black eye.

And that is exactly what makes today interesting.

What happened yesterday, in short

On Wednesday the market had welcomed the result of the midterm elections, the ones that handed the House and the Senate to the Democrats (I wrote about it here).

On Thursday it took it all back, and then some.

Index Thursday 5 November
Nasdaq Composite about -5.5%
S&P 500 about -4.4%
Dow Jones about -3.4%, more than 1,800 points

The heart of the selling was semiconductors.

Nvidia and Qualcomm lost more than 9%, AMD and Micron double digits.

The reasons, lined up by CNBC and Fortune, are three, and they added up.

Qualcomm’s disappointing guidance for the current quarter.

The doubt, going around for weeks, about how much the billions spent on data centers for artificial intelligence will really pay back.

And the vote: a Democratic Congress raises fears of more rules on AI, and in the local referendums on data centers voters said no in 40 cases out of 41, according to CNBC’s analysis of Ballotpedia data.

The result is that today’s NFP is not being read by a calm market.

It’s being read by a nervous market, one that has just found out how fragile it is.

What the market expects

The numbers, first of all.

What September Expected for October
New jobs (NFP) +29,000 +65,000
Unemployment rate 4.2% 4.2%
Hourly earnings, month on month +0.1% +0.3%
Hourly earnings, year on year +3.0% +2.9%

The consensus is the Bloomberg median, and the Reuters poll says more or less the same (other polls sit between 59,000 and 60,000).

The estimates in the Reuters poll range from 35,000 to 125,000: some, like Pantheon and MUFG, expect a number closer to 100,000.

To understand why 65,000 looks like a lot, just look at the last three months.

July was revised to -10,000, August to +133,000, September +29,000.

The average is about 51,000 jobs a month.

It’s a labour market that doesn’t fire, but hires with an eyedropper.

And on September wages there was a detail that stuck in my head: +3.0% year on year, the slowest pace since May 2021.

The clues from this week

The other data released in recent days all point in the same direction: a touch better than September.

ADP, private employment calculated by the company of the same name, said +86,000 on Wednesday, against 69,000 expected.

ISM services put its employment component at 51.4, from 50.1. Above 50 means the companies hiring outnumber those cutting, for the second month in a row.

September job openings (the JOLTS) rose to 7.5 million, with 1.06 vacancies for every unemployed person.

Careful though, because ADP and NFP are distant relatives.

They often agree, sometimes they contradict each other by 100,000 jobs.

Using ADP to guess the NFP is like checking yesterday’s weather to decide on today’s umbrella: it gives you an idea, not a guarantee.

Why this NFP weighs more than usual

Because of the Fed.

On 28 October the Fed kept rates on hold at 3.75-4.00%.

But it did so with two dissents, and both asked for a hike: Lisa Cook and Beth Hammack.

In the statement, economic growth went from “solid” to “strong”.

After that meeting rate futures gave a December hike (the meeting is on the 8th and 9th) more than an 80% probability, which fell to around two thirds after yesterday’s crash.

Translated: this is a Fed looking for a reason to hike again, not to cut.

And the labour market is the reason it’s missing, because so far it has created few jobs.

If today the labour market shows signs of recovery, the December hike becomes almost a formality.

Three scenarios, and how I read them

A number close to consensus, between 50,000 and 100,000, unemployment at 4.2%.

It’s the cleanest scenario.

Nobody has to change their mind about the Fed, and the market can go back to looking at what made it fall yesterday, that is tech.

In this case the NFP passes, and the day is decided by the Nasdaq.

A strong number, above 100,000 and even more so above 125,000, maybe with wages above the expected +0.3%, so +0.4% or more.

This is where the interesting fork opens.

In a normal market strong labour data is good news.

In this market it risks being read as “the Fed hikes in December, and maybe after that too”.

Yields up, dollar up, and more pressure right on tech stocks, which live on low rates.

MUFG, which already expects 90,000, writes that to make Treasuries sell off in a lasting way, and not just for a few hours, it would take a number around 200,000 with unemployment falling.

Below that threshold, the flare-up in yields risks being short-lived: one more reason not to chase the first few minutes.

A weak number, below 50,000, even worse if negative, with unemployment rising.

The first reflex is predictable: yields down, dollar down, the December hike moves further away.

But the day after a -5.5% on the Nasdaq, bad labour data can ignite another fear, recession.

And then the news that’s “good for rates” becomes bad for stocks.

It’s the case where the first move and the real one risk going in opposite directions.

The lesson of the day

I’ll tell you how I see it.

The same number doesn’t say the same thing on two different days.

A +150,000 a month ago would have been a breath of fresh air.

Today, with a Fed split towards hiking and a market already on the floor, it can be read, at least in the heat of the moment, as a threat.

It’s like an overtake on a race track.

The same move, at the same corner, works or ends up in the gravel depending on the tyres you have and how wet the tarmac is.

The number is the move.

The context is the tarmac.

That’s why, at 8:30, I don’t just look at the jobs figure.

I watch how the 10-year reacts in the first few minutes, and above all whether the Nasdaq future’s reaction goes in the same direction as the 10-year or not.

If yields rise and the Nasdaq falls, the market is reading “tougher Fed”.

If both fall, it’s reading “weaker economy”.

Those are two completely different days, and the headline number won’t tell you which one.

How I handle it

The rules are the same as for any big data release, only today they count double.

No positions open on the data.

Guessing the NFP is not a setup, it’s a bet with a widened spread.

The map is drawn beforehand.

Yesterday’s low on the Nasdaq future, the overnight levels, and the options walls.

After a day like yesterday market makers hedge aggressively, and gamma exposure tells you where price tends to slow down and where it risks accelerating.

I look at it on the Thunder Desk, for free, together with the macro calendar.

Size gets cut.

With yesterday’s volatility and a data release at 8:30, the stop can slip by quite a few points.

How much the worst scenario really costs me, I work out this morning, not at 8:29.

The first few minutes are not chased.

The first candle after the NFP is often noise: algorithms reading the headline, wide spreads, a thin book.

The move that matters usually shows up when the New York cash session opens, at 9:30 New York time (14:30 GMT).

And everything goes in the diary.

What I expected, what came out, how the 10-year reacted, how the Nasdaq reacted.

The next time a big data release lands on a nervous market, you’ll have a case of your own to reread.

Three points to take home

  1. Today at 8:30 New York time (13:30 GMT) the October NFP comes out. Expected +65,000 jobs, unemployment at 4.2%. This week’s ADP, ISM services and job openings point to a touch better than September.
  2. This data weighs more than usual. The Fed has just kept rates on hold with two votes to hike, and the market is pricing a December hike. A recovering labour market is the last piece it’s missing.
  3. Context matters as much as the number. The day after the Nasdaq’s -5.5%, a strong number can scare on rates and a weak one on recession. I watch how the 10-year and the Nasdaq move together, not the figure.

The same number doesn’t say the same thing on two different days. The number is the move, the context is the tarmac.

— tradingblog.itPosta su X

I’ll close with something I repeat to myself every NFP Friday.

The data comes out for everyone at the same time.

Whoever prepared beforehand only has to watch at 8:30.

Suerte Amigo!

Tiziano Brunno

Tradingblog

Want to put your market reading to the test?

Compete and challenge other traders inside an Arena in a demo environment, with no real capital at risk. Discover the Performance Arena Events by The Thunder Trader.

Discover The Thunder Trader →


Disclaimer: purely informational and educational content. It does not constitute financial advice or an invitation to trade. Trading involves the risk of capital loss.

The dome of the US Capitol in Washington backlit at night, with an amber glow on the horizon mirrored in a long reflecting pool in the foreground.

Midterms, Congress flips to the Democrats: the market sold overnight, then changed its mind

Hi trader,

if you picked up your phone last night to check the results, you did something you shouldn’t do.

And if, while you were at it, you opened the Nasdaq future chart, you saw a nice minus two percent.

This morning the same future was down only a few tenths.

What happened in between, between the night and your morning coffee, is the most useful thing I can tell you today.

What happened, in short

Yesterday’s midterm elections went to the Democrats, and not by a little.

According to CBS and CNN, the House went to the Democrats shortly after 10 p.m. New York time, that is around 3 a.m. here in the Canary Islands (UK time) and 4 a.m. CET.

The Senate a little over an hour later (the AP made the calls in the reverse order, the Senate first and the House at dawn).

The seats taken from the Republicans are seven: Texas, Ohio, Kansas, Iowa, both Carolinas, and Maine, where Susan Collins lost.

Texas and Kansas hadn’t seen a Democratic senator in decades.

Some races were still open this morning, Alaska, Mississippi and Nebraska above all (in Nebraska the challenger, Dan Osborn, is an independent), but control is no longer in question.

In plain words: from 3 January, when the new Congress is sworn in, and for the two years that remain, Trump governs with Congress against him.

Americans call it gridlock.

Laws that pass only if both sides want them, and a president who keeps his veto.

The market’s night

Here is how the market reacted overnight, according to Reuters, FXStreet and CNBC.

What Overnight At 7 this morning, UK time
Nasdaq 100 future more than -2% at the worst point about -0.3%
S&P 500 future down more than one point about -0.2%
US 10-year down 6 basis points, around 4.90% back up around 4.93%
Dollar index about -0.4/-0.5%, around 101.3
EUR/USD around 1.123
Gold above 4,000 dollars around 4,030

The first reflex was textbook.

Sell tech, because a Democratic Congress means more rules on AI and big tech, and in Texas, where the Democrats also won the governorship, some fear a slowdown on data centers.

Sell the dollar and buy Treasuries, because less room for new public spending means less deficit to finance.

Buy gold, because when in doubt you buy gold.

And then, as the hours went by, the market did what it almost always does: it changed its mind.

Why it changed its mind

For a very simple reason.

It was already priced in.

On prediction markets the Democratic “sweep”, House and Senate together, was trading at 39% in February, according to the Covers tracker.

Yesterday morning, on the eve of the vote, Kalshi and Polymarket had it around 75%.

So the scenario climbed for eight months, one piece at a time, and anyone trading had it right in front of their eyes.

Last night no surprise arrived, a confirmation arrived with the volume turned up.

The less expected part was the size: Kansas, and in Texas the governorship too, with Greg Abbott beaten.

Add that the AI story on the markets had already been creaking for a few weeks, and the overnight -2% makes more sense: expected news landing on a theme that was already fragile.

Then someone remembered two things.

The first: a different Congress doesn’t change Nvidia’s earnings next quarter.

The second is put well by Tai Hui of J.P. Morgan Asset Management, quoted by Reuters: Trump still has the power of veto.

Congress can block him, he can block Congress.

Gridlock, exactly.

And markets usually don’t do badly in gridlock: according to Bloomberg data cited by Saxo, divided government is historically the best scenario for the S&P 500 in the three months after the vote.

Michael Arone of State Street put it this way, and I’m writing it down: the big risk for markets is not the blue wave, it’s investors overreacting to the blue wave.

The lesson of the night

I’ll tell you how I see it.

The first reaction to expected news is not the real reaction.

At night, even on an election night with more volume than usual, the book is thinner than during the day.

Spreads widen, and it takes less to make a move that looks huge.

If last night you had gone short the Nasdaq at the worst point because “the Democrats won, tech is crashing”, this morning you would have been sitting there watching the future climb back, with your stop getting closer and your account getting thinner.

It’s like the start of a Grand Prix.

At the first corner anything can happen, someone goes straight on, someone gains three places.

But the race isn’t decided at the first corner.

It’s decided when the tyres have warmed up and you can see who has the pace.

What I watch today

Today the tyres warm up, because the vote isn’t the only thing on the calendar.

The market has to digest the election result and, in the same afternoon, two data releases.

When (UK / CET) What
13:15 / 14:15 October ADP, private employment. Expected around 67,000
15:00 / 16:00 October ISM services. Expected around 54.8, after 54.9 in September
Friday 13:30 / 14:30 The official employment report, the NFP. Expected around 65,000, after 29,000 in September

And above it all there’s the Fed.

On 28 October it kept rates on hold at 3.75-4.00%, but with two dissents, both in favour of a hike: Lisa Cook and Beth Hammack.

A Fed split towards hiking, a labour market creating few jobs, and from January a Congress that won’t easily expand public spending.

Those are three forces pulling yields in different directions.

That’s why today I’m not watching the vote.

I’m watching whether last night’s recovery holds at the New York open, and how the 10-year reacts to the ADP.

If the Nasdaq starts falling again on real volume after the cash open, at 15:30 CET, then the night was right.

If it holds, the night was just a night.

How I handle it

The rules are the same as on any day with a big event.

No positions built on the headline.

“The Democrats won” is not a setup.

It’s a scenario the market had been watching climb for eight months.

The map is drawn beforehand.

Overnight levels, the Nasdaq future low, the options walls on the S&P and the Nasdaq.

On days like this part of the move is made by market makers hedging, and gamma exposure tells you where the points are where price tends to stop or to accelerate.

I look at it on the Thunder Desk, for free, together with today’s macro calendar.

I open it in the morning, not when I already have a position open and I need an excuse.

Size gets cut beforehand.

With two data releases and a vote to digest in the same afternoon, the spread can widen and the stop can slip.

How much the worst scenario really costs me, I work out now, not one minute before the ADP.

And everything goes in the diary.

What I expected, what price did overnight, what it did at the open.

In two years there’s the presidential election, and that day you’ll already have a case of your own to reread.

The diary is there for exactly this.

Three points to take home

  1. Congress has gone to the Democrats, House and Senate. For two years Trump governs with Congress against him and the veto in his hand. Gridlock, and historically markets don’t mind gridlock.
  2. The overnight reaction was overdone, because the news was already priced in. On the eve of the vote the sweep was trading around 75%. The Nasdaq future hit -2% and then won back almost all of it.
  3. Today the data decides, not the vote. ADP at 14:15 CET, ISM services at 16:00 CET, and the NFP on Friday. The real test is whether last night’s recovery holds at the New York open.

A scenario the market has watched climb for months is not a surprise. It’s a confirmation with the volume turned up.

— tradingblog.itPosta su X

I’ll close with a rule I repeat to myself every time.

Election nights are made for sleeping.

Trading is done during the day, with the map in your hand.

Suerte Amigo!

Tiziano Brunno

Tradingblog

Want to put your market reading to the test?

Compete and challenge other traders inside an Arena in a demo environment, with no real capital at risk. Discover the Performance Arena Events by The Thunder Trader.

Discover The Thunder Trader →


Disclaimer: purely informational and educational content. It does not constitute financial advice or an invitation to trade. Trading involves the risk of capital loss.